Citizenship by Descent Update: From Bill C-3 to the Surrender Letters — Where Things Stand Now
Citizenship by descent has been one of the most rapidly evolving areas of Canadian citizenship law in recent years.
The current framework is the result of a constitutional challenge, a declaration that the first-generation limit was unconstitutional, repeated legislative delays, the eventual passage of Bill C-3, and significant operational challenges as IRCC implemented the new rules.
The recent suspension of citizenship certificates issued under Bill C-3 was not an isolated event. It was the result of a major transition period in which the legal framework, administrative guidance, and evidentiary expectations were all evolving at the same time.
This article provides an overview of how we arrived at the current framework, what happened with the surrender letters, and what applicants should know going forward.
Part 1: How We Got Here — The Road to Bill C-3
The First Generation Limit Is Struck Down
On December 19, 2023, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice released its decision in Bjorkquist et al. v. Attorney General of Canada, 2023 ONSC 7152.
The Court found that paragraphs 3(3)(a) and 3(3)(b) of the Citizenship Act, which limited citizenship by descent to the first generation born abroad, violated sections 6 and 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
The first-generation limit prevented Canadian citizens who were themselves born outside Canada from automatically passing citizenship to their children born abroad. The applicants argued that this created a second class of Canadian citizenship by restricting the ability of some Canadians to transmit citizenship to their children based solely on where they were born.
The Court agreed and declared the provisions to be of no force or effect.
The declaration of invalidity was suspended for six months to allow Parliament time to introduce replacement legislation.
Legislative Delay and Interim Measures
On January 22, 2024, the federal government announced that it would not appeal the decision.
Parliament did not, however, enact replacement legislation before the Court’s deadline. Bill C-71, introduced on May 23, 2024, would have implemented substantially the framework that was eventually adopted, but it did not advance and died on the Order Paper when Parliament was prorogued in January 2025. The suspension of the declaration of invalidity was extended several times — to December 2024, then to March 2025, and ultimately into January 2026 — while the government worked toward a legislative solution. Provisions that had been declared unconstitutional therefore continued to be applied to applicants for approximately two years.
On March 13, 2025, with no permanent legislation yet in place, IRCC introduced an interim measure allowing individuals affected by the first-generation limit to apply for a discretionary grant of citizenship under subsection 5(4) of the Citizenship Act.
This was an administrative workaround rather than a complete legislative solution.
A discretionary grant of citizenship operates differently from citizenship acquired by operation of law. This distinction became important once Parliament ultimately enacted a permanent solution.
Bill C-3 and the New Citizenship by Descent Framework
On June 5, 2025, the government introduced Bill C-3, An Act to amend the Citizenship Act.
The legislation created a new framework:
Individuals who had been excluded from citizenship because of the first-generation limit became citizens retroactively.
Going forward, Canadian citizens born abroad who wish to transmit citizenship to children born or adopted abroad on or after December 15, 2025 must generally demonstrate a substantial connection to Canada.
The substantial connection requirement requires a Canadian parent born abroad to have accumulated at least 1,095 days of physical presence in Canada before the child’s birth.
Bill C-3 received Royal Assent on November 20, 2025, and came into force on December 15, 2025.
Individuals who would have been Canadian citizens but for the first-generation limit became citizens by operation of law. For future generations, however, the substantial connection requirement became the central feature of the new framework.
A Significant Increase in Applications
Following the implementation of Bill C-3, IRCC experienced a substantial increase in citizenship by descent applications.
One month before the amendments took effect, IRCC told the Senate committee that it expected demand to remain manageable, estimating that applications would be measured in the tens of thousands over time rather than hundreds of thousands and noting that comparable amendments in 2009 and 2015 had produced no surge.
The actual volume exceeded those expectations.
Between December 15, 2025 and the end of January 2026, IRCC received more than 12,000 citizenship by descent applications, with American applicants filing more applications in January than the next nine source countries combined. By March 31, 2026, 4,075 individuals had received citizenship certificates under the new descent provisions, roughly half of them born in the United States.
The rapid increase in applications, combined with a new legislative framework and evolving documentary requirements, created significant operational challenges.
Processing times moved accordingly. The posted estimate for proof of citizenship stood at five months in May 2025 and approximately nine months by November 2025. It reached twelve months in May 2026, as the inventory climbed from roughly 56,000 in April to 70,400 by mid-May. By May 31 there were 82,020 applications awaiting finalization against 28,940 finalized over the preceding five months. IRCC’s position in May, as given to CBC, was that it had not seen a significant increase in application volume and had not assigned additional staff to the workload.
By the spring of 2026, applicants were also experiencing uncertainty regarding how IRCC would apply the new rules in practice.
That was the environment in which IRCC began issuing the now-infamous citizenship certificate surrender letters.
Part 2: The Surrender Letters — IRCC Reviews Bill C-3 Certificates
Over the weekend of June 13 and 14, 2026, the Registrar of Canadian Citizenship began contacting individuals who had received citizenship certificates under the Bill C-3 framework, advising them that their files had been reopened and requesting that they surrender their certificates while the department conducted a review. The letters were issued under subsection 26(1) of the Citizenship Regulations. We addressed those letters, together with a sample letter, in our earlier article on the subject.
Individuals who had received official confirmation of Canadian citizenship were suddenly being told that their certificates were being reconsidered.
The surrender letters caused significant stress for individuals whose applications had already been approved—particularly those who had already begun making arrangements to relocate or otherwise organize their lives in reliance on IRCC’s confirmation of their Canadian citizenship.
They also created considerable uncertainty for individuals in the process of preparing or submitting citizenship by descent applications, who were left questioning whether the recent legislative changes would be implemented as intended and what evidence and documentation IRCC would ultimately require to establish eligibility under the new framework.
Throughout this period, IRCC provided little to no public communication, which only heightened the uncertainty and contributed to a lack of transparency. The fact that the Department was reconsidering applications that had already been approved, despite there being no allegations of fraud or misrepresentation, made the situation even more confusing for applicants and practitioners alike.
On June 16, 2026, pressed in the House of Commons, the Minister of Immigration took the position that having a Canadian ancestor is not by itself sufficient, that the link to Canada must be established at every generation, and that genealogy websites do not meet the standard.
What Triggered the Review?
The precise reason for the review remains unclear.
On June 23, 2026, during a press conference, the Minister of Immigration stated, in response to questions from the media, that “something” had occurred which prompted the Department to undertake a review of previously approved citizenship by descent applications. However, IRCC has never publicly explained what that triggering event was or why it necessitated the reconsideration of applications that had already been approved.
It subsequently became apparent that IRCC’s concern was not with applicants’ underlying eligibility, but rather with whether the evidence submitted was sufficient to establish the required chain of descent.
Establishing a chain of descent often requires applicants to rely on historical records, particularly where citizenship must be traced through multiple generations. Depending on the circumstances, this evidence may include civil registration documents, archival records, church records, immigration records, census records, and, where official records are unavailable or incomplete, genealogical research.
The controversy was further heightened because applicants had relied on IRCC’s own published guidance when preparing their applications. Many had carefully assembled and submitted documentation that appeared to satisfy the Department’s stated requirements, only to later discover that their evidence was being assessed against criteria that had not been disclosed in the Department’s published guidance.
Blowback and IRCC’s Backtracking
On June 19, 2026, three days after the Minister’s statement, the same Registrar began issuing revalidation letters to a number of the same individuals. Those letters confirmed that the review of the file was complete, that the evidence on file supported the claim, and that the certificate would not be cancelled under subsection 26(4) of the Regulations. Recipients have reported that they filed no additional evidence between the two letters.
The significance of the episode does not lie in the number of letters issued, which was modest, but in what a six-day reversal on unchanged evidence indicates about how these files were assessed in the first place.
The Scope of the Review
IRCC subsequently confirmed that approximately 100 citizenship certificates issued under Bill C-3 had been identified for review due to concerns regarding supporting documentation.
The review was expanded to approximately 6,500 citizenship by descent applications filed under the new framework, and was completed on June 30, 2026.
IRCC confirmed that:
33 citizenship certificates were automatically reinstated after the department determined that the existing evidence established entitlement;
the remaining 67 files, representing roughly one percent of the certificates issued under the new provisions, would either be reinstated or the applicants contacted for additional information; and
the review was focused on documentary evidence rather than a change to the eligibility rules under Bill C-3.
The Changing Evidentiary Approach
On June 17 and 18, 2026, IRCC revised its application guidelines, placing increased emphasis on obtaining documentation directly from the original issuing authority and on explaining why primary documents could not be obtained.
The document checklist (CIT 0014) was also updated. Whereas the previous version required the applicant’s birth certificate and proof that at least one parent was a Canadian citizen, the revised checklist required applicants to provide proof of parentage and Canadian citizenship for their Canadian parent, grandparent, and any earlier Canadian ancestor, as applicable. It was further modified to specify that for each person in the chain, applicants were instructed to provide documents issued by the original authority.
The changes were significant because many citizenship by descent applications involve historical records where original documents may no longer exist or may be difficult to obtain. Ontario did not begin registering births until 1869, and the remaining provinces adopted civil registration on their own timelines, with the result that some lines of descent cannot be documented from a vital statistics office because no registration was ever created.
The result was a period of considerable uncertainty in which applicants and practitioners were trying to understand whether IRCC had introduced a new evidentiary requirement or was simply clarifying an existing one.
Part 3: Where Things Stand Now and What Applicants Should Do
IRCC Has Completed Its Review
IRCC confirmed on June 30, 2026, that its review of the affected citizenship by descent files was complete and that it had resumed finalizing applications.
While the immediate uncertainty created by the surrender letters has largely subsided, the episode represented another setback for public confidence in Canada’s immigration system. The lack of transparency surrounding the review process, coupled with the reconsideration of previously approved applications, left many applicants questioning the reliability and predictability of the system.
The review did not change the Bill C-3 framework. The first-generation limit has not been restored, and the eligibility rules created by Parliament remain in place.
The issue was the documentary evidence required to establish entitlement to citizenship.
The Current Evidentiary Framework
The practical lesson from the surrender letter episode is that citizenship by descent applications require careful preparation.
Although historical records and genealogical evidence remain an important part of many applications, applicants should expect IRCC to closely examine:
the source of documents;
the reliability of historical records;
the quality and legibility of the records;
the explanation for unavailable primary documents; and
the connection between each generation in the chain of descent.
For straightforward applications supported by complete civil records, these developments are unlikely to create significant challenges.
However, complex cases involving historical events, immigration, displacement, name changes, missing records, or multiple generations abroad require careful preparation.
Our Recommendations
Applicants should:
1. Obtain primary records wherever possible.
Birth certificates and records, baptismal records, marriage certificates, death certificates, and other civil status records should be obtained directly from the relevant issuing authorities where available.
2. Identify evidentiary gaps before filing.
Applicants should assess potential weaknesses in their documentation before submitting an application rather than waiting for IRCC to raise concerns.
3. Properly document genealogical evidence.
Genealogical research can be extremely valuable, but it should be supported by clear explanations regarding sources, methodology, and the connection between the records relied upon.
4. Monitor IRCC guidance carefully.
As the Bill C-3 framework continues to develop, applicants should ensure that applications are prepared using the most current instructions and documentary requirements. Our citizenship by descent FAQ and our overview of the Bill C-3 amendments address the framework and the common questions in more detail.
5. Act quickly on any adverse decision.
Citizenship matters run on a flat thirty-day period in which to seek leave and judicial review in the Federal Court under section 22.1 of the Citizenship Act, and that period applies whether the person is in Canada or abroad. It is considerably shorter than the timelines applicable to most immigration decisions and is easily missed.
Delay Is Now the More Common Problem
For most applicants, the principal concern is no longer the possibility that an approved certificate will be recalled. It is the length of time their application remains unresolved.
By July 2026, the posted processing time for proof of citizenship applications had reached nineteen months, while the inventory was approaching 100,000 files. The growing backlog stands in stark contrast to the Department’s assurances to Parliament in November 2025 that it did not anticipate a surge in applications, and its later confirmation to CBC in May 2026 that it had not allocated additional resources to process citizenship by descent applications.
Applicants are not necessarily required to wait indefinitely simply because a file remains within IRCC’s inventory. Where an application has been pending materially beyond the posted processing time, has stalled without a meaningful explanation, or has remained inactive following a request for additional documents, an application for mandamus in the Federal Court may be available.
Mandamus is a court remedy that seeks to compel IRCC to make a decision where the delay has become unreasonable. It does not guarantee approval of the underlying citizenship application, but it can require the Department to move the file forward and bring the prolonged inaction to an end.
Our firm regularly represents applicants in mandamus proceedings and has extensive experience assessing whether the circumstances of a delayed file support Federal Court intervention.
Looking Forward
The Bill C-3 amendments represented a significant correction to Canada’s citizenship laws following years of constitutional litigation and legislative delay.
The subsequent surrender letter episode demonstrated the challenges that can arise when major legislative changes are implemented quickly and administrative guidance evolves alongside them.
Citizenship by descent remains a viable pathway for thousands of individuals with a legitimate claim to Canadian citizenship. However, the recent developments reinforce the importance of carefully prepared applications supported by reliable documentary evidence.
Abramovich Immigration Law continues to monitor IRCC policy changes, legislative developments, and litigation trends affecting citizenship by descent applications.
Speak With Our Team
Whether you have received a surrender letter from the Registrar, your proof of citizenship application has remained outstanding well beyond the posted processing time, or you are preparing a citizenship by descent application and want to ensure it meets IRCC’s current evidentiary expectations, our team can help.
Our citizenship by descent practice is led by our immigration lawyer, Sara Pesko, and supported by a network of professional genealogists across Canada. We represent clients in straightforward first-generation claims, as well as complex multi-generational, historical, and pre-1947 cases requiring extensive documentary research.
Our practice extends beyond application preparation. Where IRCC delays processing unreasonably or makes an unlawful decision, we regularly represent applicants before the Federal Court.
Book a consultation to discuss your file today.